X'MAS 2014 Circe's Trials: Multi-week Contest

[StarieMichie]

4. A Gold Coin: SUCCESS  

[StarieMichie]

5. A Unicorn Carved of Stone: SUCCESS  

[StarieMichie]

5. A Bracelet of Twisted Metal : FAILURE  

[StarieMichie]

6. A Decorative Cage: SUCCESS  

[StarieMichie]

7. A Baseball: FAILURE  

[StarieMichie]

8. Polyhedrons of Chance: SUCCESS  

[StarieMichie]

9. A Collectable Plush: FAILURE  

[StarieMichie]

10. A Crown: FAILURE

Ignore this one. I can't count to 10.  

[NymiiNym]

Oh sweet siren, I can only bestow the best upon you. I fled into the night to acquire treasures fit for a princess.

1. Black Pearl: FAILURE
"I apologize for my failure. The pearl was actually a fake, and I would not dare give you anything but the truth."

2. Mysterious Silver Liquid: FAILURE
"I received a vial for a mysterious silver liquid within, but upon further investigating I discovered it was just some child's toy."

3. Coral Mirror: FAILURE
"I shouldn't have dropped your mirror.... I apologize."

4. Seaweed Necklace: SUCCESS
"I decided to atone for my previous failures by creating a necklace made of beautiful seaweed."

5. Rabbit Plushie: FAILURE
"I suppose I should have read the warning label that it did not mesh well with water."

6. Goldfish: SUCCESS
"I figured you would be lonely, and so I've brought a pet along."

7. Fallen Star: SUCCESS
"Only a star could challenge your beauty, and so I plucked it out of the sky to ensure it would never do so."

8. Unicorn Breath: FAILURE
"Sadly, I discovered the unicorn was actually a horse with a party hat on it, and it proceeded to kick me in the face."

9. Underwater Candle: SUCCESS
"So that you may never again be lost in the dark."

10. Bottled Lullaby: SUCCESS
Now you shall never endure a sleepless night again."  

[NymiiNym]

Black pearl: Fail  

[NymiiNym]

Mysterious Silver Liquid: Fail  

[NymiiNym]

Coral mirror: Fail  

[NymiiNym]

Seaweed Necklace: Success  

[NymiiNym]

Rabbit Plushie: Fail  

[NymiiNym]

Goldish: Success