RIDE MY ROLLERCOASTER OF LURVE!

[Rellik San]

bassmule

The song he chose for the video.

Bass reckons its a crap cover, but is going further to insult rancid as a whole, where as I am justifying the cover, by declaring it as a bit of fun at a live gig and most bands play a cover at live gigs.  

[Gambino Statue]

I think Bass started with the fact the song sucks as both a cover and a piece of music on the whole, but backed it up with the argument that good bands with even the slightest spark of creativity shouldn't feel the need to cover a song, and should instead try and at least attempt originality.

Do I win?  

[Rellik San]

xLIZA

I think Bass started with the fact the song sucks as both a cover and a piece of music on the whole, but backed it up with the argument that good bands with even the slightest spark of creativity shouldn't feel the need to cover a song, and should instead try and at least attempt originality.

Do I win?

Your arguing against me? lol

What do you think.

Cover versions are what makes music great, after all, are we supposed to sit back and beleive the best version of a song is that which is the first version made?

Is the Spunge version of Centrefold, not better to dance to then the G J Jiles Band version?  

[Gambino Statue]

Rellik San

xLIZA

I think Bass started with the fact the song sucks as both a cover and a piece of music on the whole, but backed it up with the argument that good bands with even the slightest spark of creativity shouldn't feel the need to cover a song, and should instead try and at least attempt originality.

Do I win?

Your arguing against me? lol

What do you think.

Cover versions are what makes music great, after all, are we supposed to sit back and beleive the best version of a song is that which is the first version made?

Is the Spunge version of Centrefold, not better to dance to then the G J Jiles Band version?

Yes, yes I am. O:

Nothing shits me more than going to see a band play the song's they've written that I love and have them play awful live covers of songs by bands they'll never be as good as.
Except maybe, idiot teenagers worshipping a screechy imitation of a great song by the latest fad act.
(Note: I'm referring to the Way/McCracken cover of the Bowie/Mercury song with that last one)

I get that they're 'all in good fun', but I don't see why a band can't have fun with their own songs instead of trying to leech popularity from an old hit.

I can honestly say I've never heard a cover I've truly believed was better than the original.
 

[Rellik San]

xLIZA

Rellik San

xLIZA

I think Bass started with the fact the song sucks as both a cover and a piece of music on the whole, but backed it up with the argument that good bands with even the slightest spark of creativity shouldn't feel the need to cover a song, and should instead try and at least attempt originality.

Do I win?

Your arguing against me? lol

What do you think.

Cover versions are what makes music great, after all, are we supposed to sit back and beleive the best version of a song is that which is the first version made?

Is the Spunge version of Centrefold, not better to dance to then the G J Jiles Band version?

Yes, yes I am. O:

Nothing shits me more than going to see a band play the song's they've written that I love and have them play awful live covers of songs by bands they'll never be as good as.
Except maybe, idiot teenagers worshipping a screechy imitation of a great song by the latest fad act.
(Note: I'm referring to the Way/McCracken cover of the Bowie/Mercury song with that last one)

I get that they're 'all in good fun', but I don't see why a band can't have fun with their own songs instead of trying to leech popularity from an old hit.

I can honestly say I've never heard a cover I've truly believed was better than the original.

Then you've been listening to the wrong bands, usually most harcore bands in the UK will do a hardcore version of something silly for an opener and then play their own stuff, and punk bands, will play covers as more to show what sort of music they like and too have a little fun, but only for an encore. I've been to a lot of gigs and thats my experiance.  

[XXX Zombie Porn]

Does it REALLY matter that ******** much?  

[xdownwithxtheshipx]

xLIZA

I think Bass started with the fact the song sucks as both a cover and a piece of music on the whole, but backed it up with the argument that good bands with even the slightest spark of creativity shouldn't feel the need to cover a song, and should instead try and at least attempt originality.

Do I win?

Not really, I don't care if bands do cover songs but they should put something new into it.

A little less Ataris Boys Of Summer, a little more Sonic Youth's Computer Age.  

[DaisukeOrDark]

xLIZA

Rellik San

xLIZA

I think Bass started with the fact the song sucks as both a cover and a piece of music on the whole, but backed it up with the argument that good bands with even the slightest spark of creativity shouldn't feel the need to cover a song, and should instead try and at least attempt originality.

Do I win?

Your arguing against me? lol

What do you think.

Cover versions are what makes music great, after all, are we supposed to sit back and beleive the best version of a song is that which is the first version made?

Is the Spunge version of Centrefold, not better to dance to then the G J Jiles Band version?

Yes, yes I am. O:

Nothing shits me more than going to see a band play the song's they've written that I love and have them play awful live covers of songs by bands they'll never be as good as.
Except maybe, idiot teenagers worshipping a screechy imitation of a great song by the latest fad act.
(Note: I'm referring to the Way/McCracken cover of the Bowie/Mercury song with that last one)

I get that they're 'all in good fun', but I don't see why a band can't have fun with their own songs instead of trying to leech popularity from an old hit.

I can honestly say I've never heard a cover I've truly believed was better than the original.

You mean like when MyChem covered Astro Zombies. *shudder*  

[Babies in the Oven]

it is cool.  

[Angel Cutter]

Vagina_The_Clown

Sorry, last time I clicked a link it was porn...ugh.

thats funny since your name has the word v****a in it.  

[Gambino Statue]

DaisukeOrDark

xLIZA

Rellik San

xLIZA

I think Bass started with the fact the song sucks as both a cover and a piece of music on the whole, but backed it up with the argument that good bands with even the slightest spark of creativity shouldn't feel the need to cover a song, and should instead try and at least attempt originality.

Do I win?

Your arguing against me? lol

What do you think.

Cover versions are what makes music great, after all, are we supposed to sit back and beleive the best version of a song is that which is the first version made?

Is the Spunge version of Centrefold, not better to dance to then the G J Jiles Band version?

Yes, yes I am. O:

Nothing shits me more than going to see a band play the song's they've written that I love and have them play awful live covers of songs by bands they'll never be as good as.
Except maybe, idiot teenagers worshipping a screechy imitation of a great song by the latest fad act.
(Note: I'm referring to the Way/McCracken cover of the Bowie/Mercury song with that last one)

I get that they're 'all in good fun', but I don't see why a band can't have fun with their own songs instead of trying to leech popularity from an old hit.

I can honestly say I've never heard a cover I've truly believed was better than the original.

You mean like when MyChem covered Astro Zombies. *shudder*

Oh God, don't even talk about it.  

[The Dadalorian]

i like the song, bass just likes to mess with him  

[Teh Evil Yoshi]

Rellik San --

Ohmygosh! I see why you're kinda ticked that he dissed your song and won't leave you alone about it, but whoa, whoa, whoawhoawhoa..

Bassmule --

Ohmygosh again to you. Whoa, whoawhoa. If you don't like the song, don't scream it and keep messing with him. He posted it cause he liked it and wanted to see if others did too.

And Oh, My, God, if this is about Rancid, I have tw-no, three songs for you people.

One:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFYmR2XAnc8

Two:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buMYRxTNifo

Three:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pD3kpgMXaWA

Ignore the strange videos, listen to the songs. Jeesh...

That's all I got. Laterss!

 

[xdownwithxtheshipx]

Chaos A.D.

i like the song, bass just likes to mess with him

That and I do hate the song and I hate Rancid as well as anything the members of Rancid have their names on.  

[Rellik San]

bassmule

Chaos A.D.

i like the song, bass just likes to mess with him

That and I do hate the song and I hate Rancid as well as anything the members of Rancid have their names on.

Psh, and you question my music taste.