Welcome to Gaia! ::

omgawd first episode was rad

The last level of From Dust is all I ever wanted form the game.

Except, It's super easy to ******** up, and there's no "undo"

It's like Final Fantasy meets Call of Duty and it is awesome.

Actually...

LA Noire... anyone played it?

It must really suck to be Fish.

It was not bad.

If you don't like GTA you won't like this game as it's essentially a GTA game where you can't run down people in your car.

I stopped cause I was horrible at it

If you're playing a horror game and you're thinking about how much fun it is, it's probably not doing a very good job as a horror game. The entire point of the genre is to scare you, and part of that is generally putting you on edge and making you worry about getting attacked by monsters. A good horror game still has to be engaging and play well and everything, but a game like Amnesia isn't bad just because the goal is a scary experience instead of a fun one.

I don't play a whole lot of artsy indie games, but a decent number apparently try to do something similar and make the player feel some other emotion(s)? If the game is boring or terrible to play, nobody's going to care about the loss of innocence metaphor or whatever. But some of the ones that people go nuts about are probably because the game was successful in making them feel sad/scared/etc.