BOOK DISCUSSION: Ashfur/Squirrelflight/Brambleclaw

[x-Shadow Wind]

The love triangle!
In my opinion, I HATE ASHFUR and he deserved to die.
heart Squirrelflight heart Brambleclaw
And do you think that Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze should've forgiven Squirrelflight? I think so, she was just trying to protect her sister.
What are YOUR opinions?  

[blazing wiind]

heart oo a Fight over love and compassion. I feel bad for squirrelflght that she had to go through that. Oh but hte fight for her love is somewhat strange. rolleyes I think ashfur is better dead i mean why not get another cat? Sheesh if Ashfur was human he needs to go to a theripist. also Jayfeather is my favorite of the cats pretty much. I felt bad when holly leaf died. Although she went a bit insane.  

[x-Shadow Wind]

Hollyleaf isn't dead! Erin Hunters said she is still alive somehow!
=D  

[valkery cain]

i love they should forgive her she only did wat waz right and took them under her wing and i cant blam ashfur he was heart hert and anger can mess up your abillity to see right and rong heart stressed sweatdrop gonk crying mrgreen rofl evil twisted wink ninja 4laugh  

[collie442]

x-Shadow Wind

Hollyleaf isn't dead! Erin Hunters said she is still alive somehow!
=D

when did they say that?if it was at the erin hunter chat then they said the they wernt gona tell us  

[x-Shadow Wind]

I don't know...but it's like all over the internet.
I've seen it a lot!