I like them. I like Bring Me to Life and my best friend likes Whisper. I like most of the songs on The Open Door, too. I wish that they'd come out with a new album soon, it's been years. I also like that cover they did on their live album. Thoughtless, I think it was.
I really wish that Amy Lee would design clothes though. If what I heard about her designing the clothes for the videos is true, she's really good at it, and she could make a lot in formal dresses.
I agree though, Amy's voice is either love it or hate it. I love it.