Welcome to Gaia! :: View User's Journal | Gaia Journals

Me:
I'm begining to see the angel look WAY too much... (-8 )
Aside from that, gorgeous color scheme (+4 ) and the subtle contrast of your copper gold and light gold with your scarf makes your avatar worth looking at more than once :]. (+2 )

8/10

Mod:@ Tekae~10/10
It looks great!

@ x-Archemetes-x~ The theme is alright. The different tattoo colors are really REALLY clashing, and the dragon is completely out of place and throwing the theme off. As well, the brown items don't seem to fit in well, color wise. The speedies and sunglasses also seem out of place with the theme, and the gold items don't match each other. 4/10

Also, when rating an avatar, please try to keep personal preferences like "I hate angelic, or I see this too much" out of the rating, and try and rate on the avatar itself. Look at how well colors match up and are balanced, and if the theme is played out well.


My Comment to Mod: Excuse me if i seemed to hit a button.
Thank you for pointing out my avi's flaws, i should work on them.
(your avi is addorable)
However my criticism was not out of place, rating is criticism.
Criticism is offering your own judgement and opinions based on observation.
(So personal opinion such as, "i'm begining to see the angel look to much" is valid)
:] thanks for the criticism.


Mod response: Thank you for taking the time to tell me how to run my thread.

later he posted AGAIN. apparently he had to take the time to look through the rules to find why i suck. xD

Mod:I would also like to point out a couple of things regarding the thread; it is an avatar rating thread. That means the avatar itself should be rated, not the personal preference of someone else. This is why it's important to put your own personal preferences aside when rating someone, and rate them solely on how well the avatar itself is put together, and how well the theme is played out. It is unfair to give a low rating due to the fact that you are tired of seeing "____" theme. That would be like downvoting someone because you don't like them. Your criticism is valid, but in the Avatar thread, please keep it to artistic criticism, not personal.

The second part:
Rule number 6 of that thread states "DO NOT contact someone over a rating in this topic. Do not fight over a rating done in this topic. Doing so is considered harassment, and may get you blacklisted from the topic or banned from the guild. ".
Please be sure to follow this rule in the future.

My Response: It might be slightly unfair :]

wow, you took the time to lookthat up for me? how thoughtful, hate to break a rule again.
talk later.

Mod: Look it up? i made those rules.

Me: Very informative ones.
Nice talking to you, is that all?

MOD: Yes, that sums it all up. Thank you for your cooperation, and happy posting.

Later that day....
MOD:
Pooplist

This is where rude people and people who do not follow the rules go. You will be put on this list so everyone can see your shameful behavior.
~
x-Archemetes-x~ For not following rules, and for being disrespectful.

If you are on this list, you are not allowed to post in this topic
~


Did you know angels fling pooh when you tell the truth?